How Great Leaders Learn to Disagree
If your goal is to grow into a leadership role, learn how to disagree.
Not to win arguments. Not to prove a point. But to help your team reach their full potential.
The best leaders I’ve worked with aren’t the loudest in the room. They’re the ones who can challenge an idea without shutting anyone down. They speak up when something doesn’t sit right, ask direct questions, and make the team better in the process.
Disagreement is uncomfortable. However, discomfort is often a signal that we’re doing real work and not just going through the motions. As Liane Davey puts it:
Conflict is uncomfortable, but it is the source of true innovation and critical for identifying and mitigating risks.
If you want to lead, don’t avoid disagreement. Learn to use it well.
What Happens When Teams Avoid Disagreement
When no one pushes back, bad ideas slip through.
I’ve seen teams ship features no one believed in. I’ve seen engineers hold back concerns until the damage was already done. Not because they didn’t care but because they didn’t feel safe speaking up.
Avoiding disagreement doesn’t create harmony. It creates risk.
A CPP global survey found that 9% of employees have seen workplace conflict cause a project to fail.
When disagreement is missing, trust erodes. Teams stop learning. And decisions get worse.
Healthy Disagreement Focuses on Ideas, Not People
Not all disagreement is helpful. Some of it creates tension and slows the team down. But when it stays focused on the work, it becomes a valuable part of the process.
There are two kinds of conflict:
- Task conflict is about ideas, plans, and priorities. It helps teams think more critically and make better decisions.
- Relationship conflict is personal. It creates stress, erodes trust, and harms team dynamics.
The key is staying focused on the problem. Ask yourself:
- Are you challenging the idea or the person behind it?
- Are you offering a better path or just trying to prove a point?
Research backs this up. Studies show that task conflict improves team outcomes, while relationship conflict consistently harms them.
Strong teams know how to disagree without making it personal. That’s a skill worth building.
|
|
Wondering If a Startup Is Right for You?
Big Creek Growth Company shares what it’s really like to work in a startup and what founders are looking for when hiring.
|
|
How to Disagree Without Creating Drag
Disagreeing with someone doesn’t have to create tension. The goal is to raise concerns, offer alternatives, and keep the conversation productive.
Here are three ways to do that:
1. Start with curiosity
Ask a question before you make a point.
“Can you walk me through why we’re going this route?”
This shows that you want to understand rather than raise an objection.
2. Be clear and respectful
If you see things differently, say so.
“I have a concern about X. Here’s what I’m seeing…”
Get to the point, and avoid softening it so much that it gets ignored.
3. Reaffirm shared goals
Remind people what you’re working toward.
“I’m aligned with the goal. I think we might be able to get there faster with this approach.”
The more consistently you do this, the more your team will come to rely on your input. That’s where leadership starts.
Build a Culture Where It's Safe to Disagree
Even if you know how to disagree well, it won’t matter much if your team isn’t used to open debate. That’s where psychological safety comes in.
People speak up when they trust that they won’t be ignored, dismissed, or punished for it. Without that trust, disagreement gets buried under silence.
Google’s Project Aristotle found that psychological safety was the strongest predictor of team performance.
You can help build that culture, even if you’re not a manager. Here’s how:
- Invite dissent. Ask, “What are we missing?” or “Does anyone see this differently?”
- Respond with respect. When someone challenges your idea, listen first. You can still disagree—but don’t shut it down.
- Model it. Admit when you’re wrong. Thank people for pointing out blind spots. Show your team it’s okay to change your mind.
Safety doesn’t mean avoiding conflict. It means your team knows how to handle it without drama.
Know When to Push and When to Let It Go
Not every disagreement is worth the effort. Good judgment means knowing when to raise the issue and when to move on.
Push when:
- A decision has real consequences.
- Something critical is being overlooked.
- The team is heading toward unnecessary risk.
Let it go when:
- You’ve made your case and been heard.
- The difference is about style, not substance.
- Continuing the debate would do more harm than good.
Being seen as a leader doesn’t come from being right all the time. It comes from knowing when to step in, when to step back, and how to do both in a way that supports the team.